A nativity scene installed by the Lake Street Baptist Church in Evanston, Illinois, has ignited significant controversy due to its stark portrayal of Baby Jesus in handcuffs, reminiscent of detainees in immigration centers. The scene, which features the Virgin Mary wearing a tear-gas mask, aims to comment on the current U.S. immigration policies under the Trump Administration, provoking both backlash and reflection within the community.
The church leaders sought to connect the sacred Christmas narrative with contemporary issues, asking themselves, “If Jesus were born in the United States right now, what would his manger look like?” The installation draws parallels between the biblical story of migration and the current plight of families facing separation and detention. Associate minister Jillian Westerfield stated their intention was to reimagine the nativity as a reflection of forced family separation, echoing the Holy Family’s flight into Egypt to escape King Herod’s persecution.
Provocative Imagery and Public Reaction
The nativity display starkly deviates from traditional holiday imagery, presenting Mary and Joseph in protective gear and Baby Jesus restrained, wrapped in an aluminum blanket like those used in immigration facilities. Nearby, masked centurions labeled “ICE” stand guard, further emphasizing the connection to contemporary immigration issues. The church describes the scene as a commentary on the increased deportations and detentions that have occurred since January, as outlined in the installation’s accompanying description.
Westerfield acknowledged that the images may be disturbing but emphasized the importance of addressing the harsh realities many face. Some critics have labeled the installation as “heresy” and “blasphemous,” leading to actions such as the removal of Mary’s mask and the zip ties from Baby Jesus, which the church had to replace.
A Call for Reflection and Change
Despite the criticism, Reverend Michael Woolf, the church’s leader, expressed hope that the discomfort caused by the nativity scene would inspire reflection on the experiences of migrant families. He highlighted the systemic issues that lead to separation, detention, and dehumanization of these families. “No one should be treated that way,” he stated, emphasizing that the installation is not a political statement but a moral one.
The church, which identifies itself as a sanctuary for undocumented immigrants, has a history of creating nativity scenes with provocative messages. In 2023, a previous display depicted Baby Jesus amidst rubble, symbolizing civilians trapped in the Gaza conflict.
As the debate surrounding this nativity scene continues, it serves as a catalyst for conversations about immigration, family separation, and the broader issues of human rights. The Lake Street Baptist Church aims not only to provoke thought but also to encourage action among community members, regardless of their faith.
