The recent AmericaFest conference, organized by Turning Point USA in December 2023, exposed significant divisions within the MAGA movement, particularly during a public dispute between conservative commentators Ben Shapiro and Tucker Carlson. Their confrontation highlighted contrasting views on controversial figures, the essence of conservatism, and the overall direction of the right-wing coalition.
During the event, Shapiro, co-founder of The Daily Wire, delivered a pointed critique of Carlson, specifically targeting his decision to platform individuals like white nationalist Nick Fuentes. Shapiro accused Carlson of promoting conspiratorial thinking and dishonesty. He emphasized that public figures have a responsibility for their guests and their messaging, referencing the late TPUSA founder Charlie Kirk and his opposition to Fuentes. Shapiro described the decision to elevate Fuentes as a “moral irresponsibility,” setting a tense tone for the conference.
As Shapiro concluded his remarks, Carlson took the stage and appeared to mock Shapiro’s critique. He dismissed the calls to “deplatform and denounce” those with differing views, calling it “hilarious” to hear such sentiments at an event honoring Kirk’s legacy. Carlson also defended himself against accusations of antisemitism, asserting his opposition to hatred based on birth. He maintained that the Trump coalition remains united, despite the evident tensions between him and Shapiro.
This public dispute underscored a broader ideological rift within the conservative movement, as both figures represented different priorities and approaches. The event revealed ongoing struggles regarding the definition of conservatism and the role of influential personalities within the MAGA coalition.
The following day, Megyn Kelly joined the conversation, publicly criticizing Shapiro for trying to act as a gatekeeper of conservative values. She announced the end of their friendship, recounting past support for Shapiro and their previous collaborations. Kelly clarified that their recent disagreements were not over their shared views on Israel but stemmed from differing opinions on Carlson’s role within the conservative movement. She rejected the notion that Carlson should be “excommunicated” from conservatism.
These internal conflicts at AmericaFest illustrate the ongoing ideological battles within the conservative movement, as various factions vie for influence and direction. The tensions between prominent figures signal a struggle for the heart and soul of the right-wing coalition, with leaders attempting to shape its future.
As these debates unfold, they highlight the complexities and evolving nature of conservative politics in the United States. The discussions at AmericaFest are likely to resonate beyond the event, influencing the broader conservative landscape as factions continue to define their identities and objectives moving forward.
