A New York school district is facing federal scrutiny for changing its team name from the “Thunderbirds” to the “T-Birds.” The U.S. Department of Education announced on March 14, 2024, that this name change violates civil rights law and is part of an effort to “erase its Native American heritage.” The federal agency indicated that the Connetquot Central School District can voluntarily address this violation by restoring the original name.
The decision to alter the team name was made in compliance with New York state regulations that prohibit the use of Native American-themed sports names and mascots. However, federal officials argue that the state mandate is inconsistent with civil rights laws. According to them, the regulations allow schools to retain names associated with other racial or ethnic groups, such as the “Dutchmen” and “Huguenots,” which raises concerns about fairness.
Kimberly Richey, who leads the civil rights office at the Education Department, expressed strong opposition to the state’s approach. “We will not allow ideologues to decide that some mascots based on national origin are acceptable while others are banned,” she stated. Richey emphasized that the current administration is committed to ensuring equal treatment under the law for all communities.
In response to the federal finding, the Connetquot Central School District stated it is reviewing the situation. Meanwhile, the New York State Education Department criticized the federal position, asserting that the conclusion “makes a mockery” of the nation’s civil rights laws. JP O’Hare, a spokesperson for the state agency, questioned the rationale behind the decision, stating, “USDOE has offered no explanation as to whose civil rights were violated by changing a team name from Thunderbirds to T-Birds.”
Last year, the school district reached an agreement with state education authorities, permitting the use of the “T-Birds” name and related imagery, such as an eagle or lightning bolt, in exchange for dropping its legal challenge to the state’s ban on Native American mascots. This agreement was part of a broader effort in New York to eliminate what advocates consider harmful and outdated depictions of Indigenous peoples.
Native American advocates highlight the significance of the “Thunderbird” as a powerful mythological creature revered in various Indigenous cultures. The controversy surrounding the name change underscores the ongoing debate over the use of Native American symbols in sports, reflecting broader societal discussions about cultural representation and respect.
As this situation unfolds, the Connetquot Central School District’s next steps will likely be closely monitored by both federal and state officials, as well as community members who have a vested interest in the preservation of cultural heritage and civil rights.
