The Miami Dolphins have decided to bench starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa in favor of rookie Quinn Ewers as they evaluate their future options. This change comes as the Dolphins face mathematical elimination from playoff contention, with their focus shifting towards assessing Ewers’ potential in the final three games of the season. Tagovailoa, who signed a substantial $212.1 million contract in 2024, may have played his final game for the franchise.
Despite the Dolphins securing five wins in their last seven games, Tagovailoa’s performance has drawn scrutiny. Over the past month and a half, he ranked 30th in QBR and 24th in passing yards, highlighting a decline that has prompted coach Mike McDaniel to make this significant decision. In a recent game against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Tagovailoa completed only 6 of 10 passes for 65 yards, with one interception that McDaniel described as a critical mistake.
The decision to bench Tagovailoa raises questions about his future with the Dolphins. Analysts suggest that he may now serve as a bridge quarterback next season or become a free agent in search of a new opportunity. His $54 million in guaranteed money makes trading him a complex issue, as teams perceive his performance this season as less than satisfactory. Concerns about his durability, especially given his concussion history, further complicate any potential move.
If Ewers performs well, he could establish himself as a viable starting option for the Dolphins, potentially alleviating the financial burden associated with Tagovailoa’s contract. The Dolphins may find themselves in a position to either reconcile with Tagovailoa, assuming he commits to improving, or explore options for a new franchise quarterback through the draft or free agency.
As it stands, Tagovailoa’s contract complicates any transition. He has $54 million guaranteed for 2026, broken down into a $39 million salary and a $15 million option bonus. Should the Dolphins release him, they would face a staggering $99.2 million in dead salary cap charges. Trading him before March 13, 2026, could mitigate some of these charges but still leaves the Dolphins in a challenging financial situation.
Coach McDaniel, who was brought in to maximize Tagovailoa’s potential, has seen mixed results. While Tagovailoa showed marked improvement in 2022, his recent struggles have led to doubts about his ability to perform under pressure. Ewers, a former three-year starter at Texas, arrives with a promising scouting report. He threw 68 touchdowns and 24 interceptions in college and possesses the accuracy needed for the Dolphins’ offensive scheme.
The Dolphins view Ewers as a developmental player with the potential to revitalize their passing game. His performance over the next few weeks will be critical, as it could either solidify his role as a future starter or force the team to reassess its strategy for the upcoming season.
As the Dolphins make this transition, the reaction within the locker room will also be pivotal. Players often have a heightened awareness of team dynamics, and Ewers’ success could invigorate a Dolphins offense that has struggled recently. Tagovailoa, despite being a team captain, has faced criticism for his comments regarding teammates and their commitment to team meetings, which could further influence team morale.
As Miami navigates this complex situation, it remains to be seen how Ewers will adapt to the challenge ahead and what it means for the franchise’s future direction. The final weeks of the season will be crucial for both the rookie quarterback and the team’s overall strategy moving forward.
