UPDATE: New insights have surfaced revealing that numerous episodes from the beloved Arrowverse are now deemed challenging to watch. Fans of the franchise, which began with Arrow on October 10, 2012, and concluded with Superman & Lois in December 2024, are revisiting these shows and finding that some episodes have not aged well.
As viewers dive back into the series, many are shocked to discover that certain storylines and dialogue have become cringeworthy, overshadowing the nostalgic enjoyment of their favorite characters. Reports indicate that the emotional weight of some episodes, combined with outdated themes, has transformed their viewing experience into something less enjoyable.
Among the episodes highlighted, Supergirl season 2’s “Mr. & Mrs. Mxyzptlk” is criticized for its portrayal of controlling behavior and outdated gender dynamics. Viewers note that the character Mon-El’s actions are particularly unsettling in hindsight. Similarly, The Flash season 1’s “All-Star Team Up” has been labeled as lackluster due to its weak villain and stereotypical characterizations, making it a common skip for fans.
The episode “Destiny” from Legends of Tomorrow stands out for its emotional impact, as it marks the last appearance of fan-favorite Leonard Snart. Although the character’s sacrifice is poignant, it casts a shadow over the rewatch experience, reminding fans of the loss.
The musical crossover episode “Duet” from The Flash and Supergirl is also called out for its disjointed narrative and unearned resolutions. Critics argue that the upbeat tone feels misplaced compared to the darker storylines preceding it.
Additionally, episodes like “Taken” from Arrow and “Heart of the Matter: Part Two” from The Flash have drawn ire for their poor writing and execution, with the latter’s lightning bolt lightsaber scene being particularly panned.
The list of hard-to-watch episodes reveals a complex relationship between nostalgia and critical viewing in today’s cultural climate. Fans are encouraged to reflect on how these episodes resonate with contemporary issues, from gender dynamics to character development.
As the Arrowverse continues to capture the hearts of fans around the globe, discussions around these troublesome episodes are likely to persist. What remains to be seen is how future adaptations and spinoffs will learn from these missteps. Stay tuned for updates on the Arrowverse and its ongoing cultural impact.
