UPDATE: The Harford County Board of Education has just announced its decision to appeal a Maryland State ruling that overturned the ban on the controversial book, ‘Flamer’, from local school libraries. The board’s motion passed by a vote of 5-2 during a special virtual session held on October 19, 2023, intensifying the ongoing debate over educational content in Harford County.
Why This Matters NOW: This appeal signals a significant clash between local governance and state oversight in educational matters. As the board seeks to regain control over its library decisions, tensions are mounting among members regarding parental rights and what materials should be deemed appropriate for students.
During the meeting, student member James McVicker III voiced his opposition to the appeal, emphasizing that the book conveys a message of “hope and resilience” for high school students, although he believes it is unsuitable for younger readers. His dissenting vote, however, did not count towards the final decision.
Background Context: The board’s action comes after the Maryland State Board of Education ruled last week to reinstate ‘Flamer’, which had been removed due to its content. The board’s counsel, Gregory Szoka, warned members that the chances of success in the Harford Circuit Court are less than 20%. He explained that the board must act swiftly, as they have 30 days from the state’s decision to file their appeal.
In a heated discussion, board members expressed varying opinions on the state’s intervention. Vice President Lauren Paige argued that state overreach threatens local voices, stating, “When the state board overrides a local decision, it sets a dangerous precedent.” Fellow board member Mark Korn echoed these sentiments, questioning the purpose of local governance if their decisions can be so easily overturned.
On the other side of the debate, Korn criticized McVicker’s view, asserting that the book’s content is not age-appropriate for students. He stated, “If there ever was a book that should be removed for being not age appropriate, it’s this book.”
Board President Aaron Poynton acknowledged the state’s rights but cautioned that such decisions should be “very narrow.” He emphasized that parents should ultimately decide what material is suitable for their children.
The Maryland State Department of Education, in its ruling, recommended that the Harford County School Board revise its book evaluation procedures. This includes enhancing transparency and providing opportunities for community participation in future reconsiderations of educational materials.
As this situation develops, the Harford County Board of Education’s next steps will be closely monitored. The appeal not only reflects ongoing concerns about educational content but also raises critical questions about the balance of power between local authorities and state governance in shaping school curricula.
Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story.
For more information, reach out to Shaela Foster at [email protected] or call 443-826-5894.
